Free Will – from theoretical philosophy to practical philosophy. A dialogue with Sandro Nannini. The article, first, reconstructs and criticizes Sandro Nannini’s incompatibilistic concept of freedom of decision and, second, develops a compatibilistic alternative, a synthesis of a rationalistic and an autonomous approach. Nannini justifies his conception primarily from a naturalistic point of view: it reflects our sense of agency, so he says. This is criticized as empirically wrong and methodically mistaken: The theory of freedom of decision is, actually, normative; it is about good decisions; naturalism cannot establish normative claims. The alternative is based, methodically, on an idealizing hermeneutics, which tries to reconstruct the point of free decisions, and then justifies the resulting concept practically: Free decisions, conceived in this way, realize optimally our autonomous desires.
Lumer, C. (2018). Libertà del volere – dalla filosofia teoretica alla filosofia pratica. Un dialogo con Sandro Nannini. In Christoph Lumer, Giacomo Romano (a cura di), Dalla filosofia dell’azione alla filosofia della mente. Riflessioni in onore di Sandro Nannini (pp. 53-84). Messina : corisco.
Libertà del volere – dalla filosofia teoretica alla filosofia pratica. Un dialogo con Sandro Nannini
Christoph Lumer
2018-01-01
Abstract
Free Will – from theoretical philosophy to practical philosophy. A dialogue with Sandro Nannini. The article, first, reconstructs and criticizes Sandro Nannini’s incompatibilistic concept of freedom of decision and, second, develops a compatibilistic alternative, a synthesis of a rationalistic and an autonomous approach. Nannini justifies his conception primarily from a naturalistic point of view: it reflects our sense of agency, so he says. This is criticized as empirically wrong and methodically mistaken: The theory of freedom of decision is, actually, normative; it is about good decisions; naturalism cannot establish normative claims. The alternative is based, methodically, on an idealizing hermeneutics, which tries to reconstruct the point of free decisions, and then justifies the resulting concept practically: Free decisions, conceived in this way, realize optimally our autonomous desires.File | Dimensione | Formato | |
---|---|---|---|
A118_Lumer_LibertàDelVolere.pdf
accesso aperto
Descrizione: Articolo principale
Tipologia:
Post-print
Licenza:
PUBBLICO - Pubblico con Copyright
Dimensione
1.14 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.14 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/11365/1089162